After two seasons of watching our favorite forensic psychologist Dr. Kirsten Bouchard (Katja Herbers), priest-in-training, David Acosta (Mike Colter), and technology contractor (Aasif Mandvi) team up to investigate extraordinary occurrences,Evilis back with its third season, and we couldn’t be happier. While the episodes will be released weekly onParamount+ from June 15, 2025, there are some other supernatural dramas you can watch in between the latest season ofEvil. Here are seven similar shows you can check out if you love all the elements of exorcism and demon possession and other creepy thingsEvilhas to offer.
Related:The Satanic Satire of ‘Evil’s Social Media and Technology Commentary
Midnight Mass (2021)
Created and directed byMike Flanagan,Midnight Massfollows the life of Riley Flynn, who returns to his isolated hometown on Crockett Island after serving some time in prison for killing someone during a drunk-driving incident.
But, as Riley returns to rebuild his life, a mysterious young priest also arrives, and soon, the small town begins to experience miraculous events and horrific omens. The miniseries was released on Netflix on July 04, 2025, and it was met with critical acclaim and won several awards including Critics’ Choice Television Awards, Writers Guild of America Awards, and Critics' Choice Super Awards.
Midnight MassstarsHamish Linklater,Zach Gilford,Kate Siegel,Rahul Kohli,Kristin Lehman,Samantha Sloyan, andHenry Thomas.
The Exorcist (2016 - 2017)
We can’t talk about religious horror shows without mentioningThe Exorcist. Although the show was short-lived and canceled after just two seasons, it gave us many scares. The first season ofThe Exorcisttells the story of Angela Rance, who suspects the presence of evil in her house after having frightening nightmares, so she turns to the progressive and compassionate Father Ortega and the abrasive and relentless Father Keane for help.
The second season focuses on Father Ortega and the newly collarless Keane as they get on the road to seek out and destroy evil. Their journey leads them to a former child psychologist who runs a group home for at-risk foster kids where one of the children is consumed by a powerful force.
LikeEvil,The Exorcisttells an exorcist story and tackles demonic possessions, and uses the marriage of science and religion to keep viewers on their toes.The Exorcistwas created byJeremy Slaterand starsAlfonso Herrera,Ben Daniels,Brianne Howey, andGeena Davis.
Constantine (2014 - 2015)
Based on the DC Comics character of the same name,Constantinetells the story of a demon hunter called John Constantine. John is struggling with his faith while haunted by his past sins and believes there’s no point in fighting for good anymore because his soul belongs to the netherworld.
But, all that changes when one of his closest friend’s daughter, Liv is targeted by demons.Constantinewas developed byDaniel CeroneandDavid S. Goyerand starsMatt Ryan,Lucy Griffiths,Angélica Celaya,Charles HalfordandHarold Perrineau.
AlthoughConstantinelasted for only one season, fans ofEvilwill enjoy the show for its exorcism and occult elements.
Supernatural (2005-2020)
With 15 seasons containing 327 episodes, this long-running fantasy drama about two brothers hunting demons, ghosts, and other supernatural beings is just what fans ofEvilshould dig into next.
Created byEric Kripke,Supernaturalfollows Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean (Jensen Ackles) as they walk in their father’s footsteps as hunters who fight off supernatural evil from the earth. Other cast members ofSupernaturalincludeJim Beaver,Misha Collins, andMark Sheppard.Supernaturalaired on The WB from 2005 to 2006 and moved to The CW where it aired from 2006 to 2020.
Supernaturalhas been nominated for and has won many awards including People’s Choice Awards, Constellation Awards, SFX Awards, and 3 Primetime Emmy Awards nominations.
Preacher (2016 - 2019)
Based on the comic book series of the same name which was created byGarth EnnisandSteve Dillon,Preacherwas developed bySam Catlin,Evan Goldberg, andSeth Rogenfor AMC and follows a hard-drinking chain-smoking preacher called Jesse Custer. Custer gets extraordinary powers and to better understand his powers and literally find God, he enlists the help of a vampire and his ex-girlfriend.
Preacherran for four seasons and was nominated for many awards including the Saturn Awards for Best Horror Television Series for two consecutive years. The show starsDominic Cooper,Joseph Gilgun, andRuth Negga.
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (2018 - 2020)
Chilling Adventures of Sabrinais a supernatural horror show based on the Archie comic book series of the same name written byRoberto Aguirre-Sacasa. The show was developed by Aguirre-Sacasa for Netflix and was produced byCraig Forrest,Ryan Lindenberg, andMatthew Barry.
The show follows the Archie comic character, half-human half-witch Sabrina Spellman, who must choose between her new witch world where her family is and her human world where her friends are.Chilling Adventures of SabrinastarsKiernan Shipka,Ross Lynch,Lucy Davis,Tati Gabrielle,Michelle Gomez,Chance Perdomo,Jaz Sinclair,Lachlan Watson,Richard Coyle,Miranda Otto, andGavin Leatherwood.
Although Netflix canceled the show in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic, if you enjoyedEvil, you will enjoy watching Sabrina fight to take her place in her family’s legacy in the Church of Night.
Related:‘Evil’ Creators Robert & Michelle King on Season 3 and the David/Kristen Relationship
American Horror Story: Asylum (2012 - 2013)
American Horror Story: Asylumis the second season of the horror anthology series,American Horror Story, which was created byRyan MurphyandBrad Falchuk. Although the season intercuts between different timelines from the past and the present, the show is set mostly in 1964 at a fictional mental institution called Briarcliff Manor and focuses on the stories of the staff and inmates who occupy the institution.American Horror Story: AsylumstarsJessica Lange,Zachary Quinto,Lily Rabe,Sarah Paulson,Evan Peters,Frances Conroy, andDylan McDermott.
